Three Pairs Bought, Two Returned: The Fit Problem

ReBorn Designs / Read Time: 8 min

"I’m a size 8 in Brand A, a 9 in Brand B, and a 10 in Brand C. I always buy three pairs of shoes just to find one that fits, and then return the other two.”

Two different people told me the same thing in just one week. One had just returned her third pair of sneakers in a month. Each looked great, but not a single one fit the same

This isn’t unusual. Across categories—athletic, casual, even premium—fit inconsistency is one of the biggest frustration for buyers. With more shoes on the market than ever, why do so many brands still fail at the most basic expectation: making shoes that actually fit?

The answer?

The brief is broken.

At Sperry, we faced a common industry challenge: internal debates about how much fit should remain tied to the brand’s legacy identity, especially in programs that still carried equity from the former product name. Some argued we had to use the same lasts, even when they didn’t deliver proper fit for new styles.

Enter Paul Deering, our Director of Women’s Development, who casually coined the perfect phrase: “Fit Identity.” It was a strategy to separate the brand’s fit philosophy from any single last, ensuring that fit remained a defining part of the product while giving designers the freedom to adapt shapes as needed.

Instead of vague briefs like:
"Create a stylish, versatile boat shoe for summer,"

we reframed it around a real consumer problem:
"Women with wider feet are constantly returning shoes because the toe box is too narrow. How can we design new styles that honor the brand’s heritage while accommodating these consumers?"

By translating this frustration into measurable objectives, we were able to:

• Standardize fit principles across collections without being locked into legacy lasts

• Adjust toe boxes, midsoles, and heel shapes for real consumer comfort

• Reduce complaints caused by narrow sizing

The result: shoes with improved fit, fewer returns, and stronger consumer trust. Fit Identity became the guiding principle for future collections, proving that clear, strategic briefs lead directly to product success.

Want to see the impact in action? Check out how one shoe generated $550,000 in additional sales in a single season by focusing purely on fit principles here.

Why Consumers Are So Frustrated

The truth is:

• Fit inconsistency is avoidable. Brands just aren’t asking the right questions.

• Designers can’t solve problems they don’t know exist.

• “Trendy” and “fast” are prioritized over durability, comfort, and accuracy.

Most briefs fail because they ask about aspiration instead of pain. They focus on style instead of function. And the consumer suffers.

At ReBorn Designs, we don’t just create footwear concepts. We ensure they actually work for real consumers. If you’re tired of seeing inconsistent sizing and fit issues derail your best designs, book a free 30-minute Discovery Call and let’s transform your briefs into shoes that truly satisfy.

The Formula for Bulletproofing Your Brief

1. Start with the Pain Point, Not the Aesthetic
   Ask: “Where are consumers actually struggling?” Not: “What colors do you like?”

2. Translate Complaints into Measurable Problems
   Example: Heel slip → last shape. Flattened insoles → material choice. Size inconsistency → internal grading system.

3. Set Clear, Testable Goals
   Instead of “improve comfort,” specify: “Ensure 90% of repeat customers can buy their normal size without adjustment.”

4. Validate with Real Consumers Before Design
   Use focus groups, wear-tests, or surveys to confirm the problem statement resonates.

5. Align the Entire Team Around the Problem
   Marketing, product development, and design should all understand: we are solving this problem first; style comes second.
   
   Want to see how we test and validate every detail before a shoe hits production? Learn how ReBorn Designs turns real consumer insights into actionable design solutions with Mesh01.

Designers Thrive When Briefs Are Clear

A designer can’t deliver a perfectly fitting sneaker if the brief doesn’t define fit as a goal. But with the right insights, solving basic issues like sizing, comfort, and durability becomes not just possible, but obvious.

Start with the consumer problem, not the next trend. Because if you solve the real pain, everything else—style, marketing, loyalty—follows naturally.

The question is: what consumer frustration in your line hasn’t been solved yet?

Cheers!
Erin

Powered by ReBorn Designs

PS: If you’re ready for more, here are other ways I can help:

• If you have any questions, reply to this email.

• Need more guidance? Hop on a Discovery Call & let’s talk more.

• Follow me on LinkedIn for bite-sized tips throughout the week (free)